2 Ingredient Cottage Cheese Ice Cream – The High-Protein Sweet You Didn’t See Coming

Let me tell you 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream was never part of my meal plan. One night, the kids were finally in bed, and I was staring into the fridge hoping something dessert-y would magically appear. There it was: half a tub of cottage cheese and a lonely frozen banana. I threw them in the blender, just hoping for something edible. But what came out? Creamy. Sweet. Cold. A total surprise. I handed a spoonful to my husband, and he raised his eyebrows, “Wait this is cottage cheese?”

Since that late-night experiment, it’s become our go-to post-dinner treat. It takes less than five minutes to throw together and checks every box: creamy like real ice cream, sweet enough to satisfy cravings, and packed with protein. And it’s not just a random kitchen hack—it’s a full-blown viral trend for a reason. This 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream is blowing up on TikTok and making waves with healthy eaters who want quick wins without compromise.

So, whether you’re counting macros or chasing toddlers all day, this is your answer to “What can I eat that feels like dessert but doesn’t wreck my goals?” You’re about to see why this 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream recipe isn’t just smart it’s seriously good. And the best part? You only need two ingredients.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Print

What You’ll Need for 2 Ingredient Cottage Cheese Ice Cream

Just Two Things You Already Have in Your Fridge

The magic of 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream is right there in the name. All you need is:

• Full-fat cottage cheese
• Frozen fruit (like banana, mango, strawberries—your call)

Seriously, that’s it. The cottage cheese brings the creamy texture and protein, while frozen fruit sweetens it up and helps it whip into a thick, scoopable ice cream. Bananas make it super smooth. Mango gives it that tropical sorbet feel. Want extra fiber? Toss in frozen berries.

No added sugar, no heavy cream, no ice cream machine. Just real ingredients, real fast.

And let’s be honest: it’s a win when you can use what’s already sitting in your fridge to whip up dessert in five minutes flat.

Optional Add-Ins That Change the Game

If you want to take this cottage cheese ice cream to the next level (without adding much effort), here are a few add-ins we love:

• Peanut butter or almond butter – turns it into a frozen protein bowl
• Cocoa powder or chocolate chips – for that chocolate craving
• Maple syrup or honey – optional if your fruit isn’t sweet enough
• Vanilla extract – adds a classic dessert flavor
• A pinch of salt – surprisingly helpful to balance sweetness

These extras don’t cancel out the simplicity. Think of them like toppings on your favorite froyo. The base stays the same: still just 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream at heart.

How to Make Ice Cream with Just Two Ingredients

Blend, Freeze, Stir, and Scoop

You’re just a few steps away from enjoying a creamy bowl of 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream, and yes—it’s really that easy.

Step 1: Blend your base
Start by blending 1 cup of full-fat cottage cheese with 1 frozen banana (or frozen mango, strawberries, or any fruit you love). Use a high-speed blender or food processor for best results. Blend until the mixture is completely smooth and thick, like soft-serve ice cream. Make sure there are no lumps—this is key to getting that perfect texture.

Step 2: Freeze for scoopability
Pour the mixture into a small freezer-safe dish or loaf pan. Spread it evenly and cover. Place it in the freezer for 2 to 3 hours. For best texture, stir it once halfway through to prevent it from hardening too much around the edges. This keeps your 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream creamy and easy to scoop.

Step 3: Scoop and serve
Once the mixture is frozen but still soft enough to scoop, serve it in bowls just like traditional ice cream. You can enjoy it plain, or add some healthy toppings—try chopped nuts, a drizzle of honey, fresh berries, or a sprinkle of dark chocolate.

Step 4: Freeze longer if needed
Prefer a firmer ice cream? Let it freeze for an additional 1 to 2 hours. Before serving, allow it to sit on the counter for 5–10 minutes so it softens just enough to scoop easily.

This recipe is incredibly flexible. Whether you want soft-serve style or a firm scoop, 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream adjusts to your taste and timing. Plus, it’s a great way to enjoy dessert without the sugar crash.

Why Is My Cottage Cheese Ice Cream So Hard or Grainy?

Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them

If your 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream came out rock solid, chalky, or icy, don’t worry—it’s fixable. Because this recipe skips the cream and stabilizers found in commercial ice cream, a few key things help preserve that smooth, scoopable texture.

Mistake 1: You didn’t blend it long enough.
If the cottage cheese isn’t completely smooth before freezing, you’ll notice a gritty texture. Blend until it’s ultra creamy—no tiny curds visible.

Mistake 2: You skipped the mid-freeze stir.
If you forget to stir the mixture halfway through freezing, ice crystals can form. Stirring after about an hour helps prevent this and keeps the ice cream soft.

Mistake 3: You used low-fat or dry cottage cheese.
Higher-fat cottage cheese creates a richer texture. If you use low-fat, the result may be icier. You can add 1–2 tablespoons of Greek yogurt or a splash of milk to improve creaminess.

Mistake 4: You froze it too long.
After more than 3–4 hours in the freezer, it naturally firms up too much. Just let it sit at room temp for 10 minutes before scooping.

How to Get That Ultra-Creamy Finish

If you want your 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream to look and feel like premium store-bought pints, here are a few pro tips:

• Add half a ripe banana for extra smoothness
• Toss in 1 tbsp of honey, maple syrup, or peanut butter to prevent over-freezing
• Blend with a little Greek yogurt or full-fat milk if your base seems too thick
• Try a food processor instead of a blender—it gives better control over texture

This high-protein treat can definitely mimic real ice cream—you just need the right blend and freeze routine. Once you dial in your texture, you’ll be making this again and again.

Is Cottage Cheese Ice Cream Healthy? Yes—and Here’s Why

High Protein, Low Sugar, Gut-Friendly

One of the best things about 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream is that it’s actually good for you. Unlike traditional ice cream that’s packed with added sugars and heavy cream, this version delivers serious nutrition in every scoop.

Cottage cheese is loaded with protein—up to 15 grams per serving—and contains casein, a slow-digesting protein that helps you feel full longer. When you pair it with fruit like bananas or berries, you’re getting fiber, natural sweetness, and even a few antioxidants.

What you won’t find? Added sugar, artificial flavors, or unnecessary calories. This makes 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream perfect for clean eating, low-carb plans, or anyone who wants a treat without the crash later.

Weight Watchers and High-Protein Snack Approved

If you’re tracking macros or on Weight Watchers, this is a win. It fits easily into most healthy lifestyles and makes an ideal post-workout snack, especially when made with banana or peanut butter for extra fuel.

We’ve even started prepping small batches ahead for grab-and-go desserts. Once you try 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream, it becomes part of your weekly routine. It’s that easy—and that satisfying.

How to Store and Enjoy It Different Ways

Storage Tips for Better Texture

Once you’ve made a batch of 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream, the next step is storing it right—because yes, the texture can change a bit over time.

Always keep it in an airtight container to prevent ice crystals from forming. For best results, stir it halfway through freezing and again before serving. If it becomes too firm, just leave it out for 5–10 minutes to soften before scooping.

We also like dividing it into small portions using silicone molds or freezer-safe cups. That way, you always have a scoop ready no need to thaw the whole batch.

5 Easy Flavor Variations to Try

The beauty of 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream is how versatile it is. Once you’ve nailed the base, try these easy add-ins:

• Strawberry banana + vanilla
• Mango + lime zest
• Peanut butter + cocoa powder
• Frozen cherries + almond extract
• Blueberries + lemon

You can also top it with granola, chopped nuts, or melted dark chocolate. However you spin it, 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream fits any craving while keeping it simple and healthy.

Conclusion

Whether you’re after a quick healthy dessert or something to satisfy your sweet tooth without guilt, 2 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream delivers every time. It’s creamy, customizable, and takes just minutes to prep.

The best part? You’re in control. With just cottage cheese and frozen fruit, you’ve got a base that’s endlessly versatile. From peanut butter and chocolate to mango and lime, you can make a new version every week without getting bored.

This recipe has become a staple in our kitchen—right alongside our protein-packed buffalo chicken dip and Bagel Cottage Cheese Breakfast Tacos. Try it once, and we’re pretty sure you’ll be hooked too.

👉 Discover more delicious visuals and ideas on our Pinterest page.

FAQs About 2 Ingredient Cottage Cheese Ice Cream